We Tried the Best Polo Shirts for Men in 2025—Here’s Our Ranking
Polo shirts are either boring or bold—and finding one that feels just right is harder than it should be. They ride that tricky line between dressy and casual, promising effortless cool but often delivering stiff collars, boxy fits, or flimsy fabrics. For years, polos have been a fallback in every guy’s wardrobe: dependable, yes—but rarely inspiring. That’s exactly why we decided to take a fresh look at what’s out there in 2025.
This year, polo shirts are having a quiet renaissance. Brands are blending comfort with clean tailoring, experimenting with elevated fabrics, and designing fits that actually fit. So, we rolled up our sleeves (literally), put them to the test, and picked three contenders that claim to have perfected the modern men’s polo. We tried them in real life—from morning coffee runs to last-minute Zoom calls and low-key dinners out.
Our lineup? Mott & Bow, Everlane, and Buck Mason. And spoiler alert: one of them stood way above the rest. Whether you’re after stylish polos for men, building a smart casual polo outfit, or just want a piece that finally lives up to its promise—this list is for you.
We judged each on fit, fabric, versatility, and that hard-to-define quality: do you actually want to wear it again? And while all three had their strengths, let’s just say the Mott & Bow polo review surprised even us—for all the right reasons.
What Makes a Great Polo in 2025?
The polo shirt has come a long way since its days as a stiff country club staple. In 2025, the best polo shirts for men aren’t just wardrobe fillers—they’re smart, versatile staples that check several key boxes.
First up: the fabric. If it doesn’t feel soft against your skin, it’s a non-starter. Today’s top polos use premium cotton or cotton blends that bring both comfort and longevity. Whether it’s Pima, jersey, or slub, the right weave makes a huge difference in breathability and structure.
Fit matters more than ever. A modern polo should flatter your frame without clinging like activewear or draping like a tunic. The shoulders should sit right, the sleeves should hit mid-bicep, and the body should gently taper. It’s the kind of cut that works whether you’re ripped, lean, or somewhere in between—a must for modern men’s polos.
Breathability is non-negotiable, especially when you want to dress up without overheating. But that doesn’t mean sacrificing polish. The best polos manage to feel breezy while still holding their shape throughout the day.
And versatility? That’s the hidden superpower. The ideal polo slides easily into a smart casual polo outfit—pair it with dark denim, chinos, or even layer it under a lightweight jacket. It works for casual Fridays, patio drinks, and even date night without skipping a beat.
Last but not least: no loud logos or trendy distractions. The best polos in 2025 feel timeless, not try-hard. That’s why minimal branding and classic colorways are winning.
The Top 3 Polo Shirts for
Men in 2025
After testing, wearing, and even washing these polos, here’s how the top contenders stacked up. Each had a unique appeal, but one brand came out on top as the ultimate pick for the modern man’s polo wardrobe.
______
01.
Mott & Bow – Jersey Sueded Polo
“
It feels like luxury.
Looks like effort. Wears
like your favorite tee.”
This is where comfort meets polish. Mott & Bow’s Jersey Sueded Polo hits every note: made from buttery-soft sueded cotton, it feels incredibly smooth to the touch while offering just enough stretch for everyday movement. The tailored fit strikes the perfect balance—clean and refined, never clingy or stiff.
Visually, it nails the essentials: minimal branding, timeless colorways, and a silhouette that works with everything from jeans to chinos. Whether you’re headed into a meeting or grabbing rooftop drinks, this one always feels right.
Verdict: Best all-around polo for modern everyday wear
This is the Mott & Bow men’s polo review we were excited to share—and yes, it lives up to the hype.
And for guys who want the same flattering fit with elevated function, Mott & Bow now offers the Luxe Performance Polo—a polished upgrade perfect for everything from the office to the golf course.
With a sleek, modern design and a fabric that feels cool, breathable, and smooth like silk, it’s built to keep you fresh, wrinkle-resistant, and comfortable from your morning tee time to a dinner out. It’s an ideal pick for men who want style that performs without sacrificing sophistication.
Up to 10% OFF with Mott & Bow Polos
BUY MORE, SAVE MORE – get up to 10% OFF when you bundle multiple pairs
LIMITED QUANTITIES AVAILABLE
______
02.
Everlane – Organic Cotton Polo
Everlane’s take on the polo is classic with an eco-conscious twist. The organic cotton offers a clean aesthetic and a relaxed silhouette that leans more casual than tailored. It holds its shape well and has decent structure, but if you’re after supreme softness, it might leave you wanting.
Still, for guys who prefer minimalist design with sustainable appeal, this is a solid choice—especially at the price point.
Verdict: Best minimalist pick on a budget
A respectable contender in the world of stylish polos for men—just not the softest ride.
“
Understated and
conscious.”
______
03.
Buck Mason – Cedar Avalon Knit Polo
“
Vintage feel with a
modern twist.”
The Buck Mason Cedar Avalon Knit Polo channels old-school Americana in all the right ways. The heavier, textured cotton delivers a rugged vibe with just enough tailoring to keep things modern. It feels more like a weekend shirt for a guy who’s into heritage style than a sleek wardrobe staple.
If you lean classic and don’t mind the added weight, this one definitely has personality.
Verdict: Best for guys who like a classic, masculine vibe
A strong niche entry, but not the most versatile for a smart casual polo outfit.
How to Style a
Polo in 2025
After wearing and comparing the top contenders, one brand clearly stood out. Mott & Bow takes the win. It delivers on fit, feel, and versatility—the three things that matter most when picking the best polo shirts for men in 2025.
It’s not just the buttery-soft fabric or the tailored silhouette—though both are standouts. It’s how easy the Mott & Bow polo is to wear, how it effortlessly fits into a smart casual polo outfit, and how it makes you feel put-together without trying too hard. This is the kind of shirt you throw on in the morning and still feel good in by nightfall.
Whether you’re after stylish polos for men, building a capsule wardrobe, or just looking for a reliable everyday staple, the Mott & Bow polo review says it all: this is the one that nails it.
So if you’re building your rotation of modern men’s polos, start here. You won’t just wear it—you’ll rely on it.
Final Verdict: Which is the Best Polo for Men?
After wearing and comparing the top contenders, one brand clearly stood out. Mott & Bow takes the win. It delivers on fit, feel, and versatility—the three things that matter most when picking the best polo shirts for men in 2025.
It’s not just the buttery-soft fabric or the tailored silhouette—though both are standouts. It’s how easy the Mott & Bow polo is to wear, how it effortlessly fits into a smart casual polo outfit, and how it makes you feel put-together without trying too hard. This is the kind of shirt you throw on in the morning and still feel good in by nightfall.
Whether you’re after stylish polos for men, building a capsule wardrobe, or just looking for a reliable everyday staple, the Mott & Bow polo review says it all: this is the one that nails it.
So if you’re building your rotation of modern men’s polos, start here. You won’t just wear it—you’ll rely on it.
